Comments

  • OPen the windows when the a/c is broken. Otherwise you’re riding around in a stale hot car…ughhh.

    Posted by mrmarootie
    on July 22nd, 2008 at 4:53 pm

  • I hear that the E and F lines will get new cars eventually but not sure when.

    Older R32’s are being phased out. R46’s are being refurbished and could move to other lines than the E and F in the future.

    Posted by Subway cars
    on July 22nd, 2008 at 5:20 pm

  • There is no need for a log. Older R32’s phase 2 are being phased out and replaced with Phase 1. R46’s are being refurbished and are in overhaul mode as we speak. I think the terminology used was SMB.

    Try http://www.nytransitforums.com since they have detailed info about what is going on. Eventually the E and F lines will have brand new subway cars. The question is when the R160B or R179 will makes its way to the system. It could be a few years away still.

    Posted by No need for log
    on July 22nd, 2008 at 5:24 pm

  • Correction on the website. http://www.nyctransitforums.com

    Posted by Correction
    on July 22nd, 2008 at 5:25 pm

  • The Queens Blvd IND Subway is 72 years this year. Not only are the stations decrepit and beg an overhaul (modernization), but the line uses some of the oldest equipment in the system. Those corrugated-sided E trains are the oldest in NYC.
    Letters to Congressman Anthony Weiner (former US congressional transportation committee chairman) and Mr. Lee Sander have yet to be replied to.
    The 700,000 daily riders, the second busiest behind the Lexington, have every right to be outraged. BUT, we must all write, call, and harass those in charge until we get some semblance of civilized service.
    Go to any other major national or international city and see what can be done—clean, cool, sleek, and prompt, all on a smaller budget.

    Posted by Visionary
    on July 22nd, 2008 at 5:33 pm

  • The MTA has agreed to cutting the budget as well as a fare increase. There is a meeting scheduled tomorrow morning I believe and a hearing on federal funding which is public in August.

    The E trains are the R32 and are of stainless steel design and are very reliable trains. The Phase 2 have squeaking breaks while the phase I cars do not.

    The orders for new subway cars have already been in place with Kawasaki and Alstom. Alstom is slow on delivery while Kawasaki has delivered better cars and at a faster pace to boot. It is unclear if the R160B option 1 will go on the E or F at this time. The cars coming in now have gone to the N and the W. The next batch will go to the Q in the fall. The next batch could possibly go to the E or F after that. It is unclear at this time.

    Posted by Letter Writing
    on July 22nd, 2008 at 6:37 pm

  • Letter Writing won’t speed up the process for new cars which is in place or account for the budget shortfalls since this is where the whole problem lies right now.

    Posted by Letter Writing
    on July 22nd, 2008 at 6:39 pm

  • R160s are coming in all the time!

    Posted by R160's
    on July 22nd, 2008 at 7:07 pm

  • Where are these new cars? The E trains are old, hot and loud. The F’s are newer and better, but still get hot. Of course if this were a Manhattan line, like the 1,2,3 or 4,5,6 we’d have new cars. Interesting how one of the busiest lines, the E, which serves Queens is treated as a step child and continues to have the old decrepit cars.

    Posted by KGResident
    on July 23rd, 2008 at 9:40 am

  • The new cars are on order and have been for awhile. Its just a matter of time. The E/F line will be all R160 and/or R179 and will have the newest cars in the fleet once they are replaced.

    Posted by NewCars
    on July 23rd, 2008 at 9:50 am

  • Alstom is shitty on deliveries and quality, the MTA has already considered suing them. Kawasaki cars are coming in all the time regularly.

    Just be patient.

    Posted by NewCars
    on July 23rd, 2008 at 9:52 am

  • Patient? Why, we’ve been waiting for sooo long, yet I see new cars all the time on the 4/5/6 and 1/2/3 and the L is all new. The E, well I guess who cares, we’re Queens … and they want 8% increases and then another set of increases in 18 months following that. Perhaps if they cut their management fat by 8% they would find the money to keep the system current without strangling the ridership. Which, by the way is up so where’s that money going? Oh I forgot, the MTA keeps two sets of books.

    Posted by KGResident
    on July 23rd, 2008 at 11:20 am

  • That is BS. The new cars are being added right now to the N, W and Q in the fall. The BMT/IND are getting new subway cars as we speak.

    Posted by NewCars
    on July 23rd, 2008 at 11:43 am

  • I got a similar response when I wrote to the MTA asking why there are no elevators at 71st-Continental - a nabe with a very large eelderly population: be patient, their coming by 2025.

    Thanks for all this interesting and fascinating information, everyone, but as the old saying goes, “that and a token will get me on the subway!!”

    Posted by Mickie T
    on July 23rd, 2008 at 1:44 pm

  • The MTA will do it before 2025 because mass transit is being heavily used and they will get more federal funding once we see a shift in presidential leadership.

    Just sit tight. More infrastructure dollars will come.

    Posted by MassTransit
    on July 23rd, 2008 at 2:10 pm

  • 382 ‘B’ Division Cars (R-160 Option 2) require federal funding approval. A few of these could be put on the E or F lines. Hearing is scheduled for August. Either the last end of these or the R179 will go on the E and F. Not sure yet as to which.

    Posted by MTA Federal hearing
    on July 23rd, 2008 at 2:18 pm

Post a Comment

It’s the oldest established permanent underground sweat-lodge in New York

Posted by Mickie T on Tuesday, July 22nd, 2008

…otherwise known as The ‘E’ Train!!

August 3, 12008 - UPDATE:

As discussed in the forum, the local news media picked up the “HOT” story (couldn’t resist) of lousy a/c on the E train. The E train is at the bottom of the ice bucket, according to this cool chart from The Daily News, and the only line that didn’t break the 90% pass rate.

Photo: Newsday

Only 83% of the E train cars were 78 F degrees or cooler, and if you think that’s not SO bad, consider how warm a threshold 78F is. Who’s idea was that, some skinny people with no body fat like Ashley and Mary-Kate? I bet if the threshold were set at a more comfortable level, such as 73F, many more cars would fail.

I ride the E train everyday to the World Trade Center, and it bewilders me to see groups of tourists - both foreign and domestic, native-English-speaking and those learning a few phrases - sitting in hot cars. If I walk through one, I even tell people, “It’s very hot in here. The a/c is broken. You can move to a cooler car, you know.” And they just look at me like I’m just wishing them a good morning. I know that the London Underground does not have a/c, but that doesn’t mean you have to suffer like back home

********************************

Just as I was about to start this entry, QC Forum participant nycdude posted this form-letter response from the MTA:

07/22/2008 10:23 AM This is in response to your recent e-mail message to MTA New York City Transit regarding the cooling system on our subway cars.

We regret any unpleasant conditions you have encountered in the subway. Our subway cars are designed so that the air conditioning comes on automatically when the temperature of the car exceeds 71 degrees Fahrenheit, and the heat comes on when the temperature drops below 54 degrees Fahrenheit. Unfortunately, an air conditioning or heating unit may sometimes malfunction during the course of a train’s run. Our maintenance personnel will continue their routine inspection of all climate control systems to ensure that they are functioning properly.

In the future, should you have further transit-related concerns, we will need a car number or employee badge number so that we can investigate the problem and take the appropriate measures as warranted. You may contact Customer Services at (718) 330-3322, open from 9:00 a.m. to 5:00 p.m., weekdays, to report this information.

We take the concerns of our customers seriously and thank you for bringing this matter to our attention.

La Wanda C. Green
Associate Transit Customer Service Specialist II

Thank you, nycdude, for posting that.

Now, my questions for QC readers are:

  1. Who among us is going to write down or memorize the car numbers of the E trains with broken a/c systems? I’m actually not being rhetorical. Let’s keep a log!
  2. When I’m stuck in a hot car on the E train, I try to open at least two windows to get some air circulation. Invariably, someone will snap at me, saying, “You’re only making it worse!!!”

When subways cars didn’t have a/c (uh…my grandparents told me about it…), the ceiling fans were on and the windows were open. Even during the 1980s, when a/c was standard but usually broken (my parents told me about that…), people would gladly open car windows. That’s how you knew a car was hot when it pulled into the station.

So, dear readers, what do you think? Is a subway car with no a/c but a couple of open windows worse than a completely sealed car with no a/c, in the hopes you’re containing that one last pint of formerly cold air?